بررسی و تحلیل ماهیت قدرت نرم در سطح دولت-ملت ها

نوع مقاله : مقالات علمی -پژوهشی

نویسندگان

• سیدجواد موسوی زارع ¹
• سید هادی زرقانی ²
• مصطفی امیر فخریان ³

¹ دانشجوی دکتری جغرافیای سیاسی، دانشگاه فردوسی مشهد، مشهد، ایران

² دانشیار جغرافیای سیاسی، دانشگاه فردوسی مشهد، مشهد، ایران

³ استادیار جغرافیا و برنامه‏ریزی شهری، دانشگاه فردوسی مشهد، مشهد، ایران

https://doi.org/10.22067/pg.2021.39642

چکیده

قدرت نرم و تجلی آن از جمله مباحثی است که به یاری جوزف نای به محافل دانشگاهی و سیاستگذاری راه پیدا کرده است.علیرغم اقبال گسترده به این مفهوم، عدم تبیین نظری دقیق از سوی نای، ابهامات متعددی را حول این شکل از قدرت رقم زده است.به طوریکه باوجود انبوهی از ادبیات، پژوهشگران هنوز درک کامل از ماهیت قدرت نرم ندارند. اینکه به واقع قدرت نرم چیست؟ و از چه عناصری شکل گرفته است؟ مسائلی است که هنوز پاسخ معتبری برای آنها یافت نشده .به همین منظور این پژوهش با اتکا بر نظریه داده بنیاد و تحلیل محتوا درصدد فهم عناصر موثر بر این قدرت در سطح دولت-ملت هاست.بر این اساس یافته های علمی پژوهش حاکی از این دارد اگر عناصر قدرت نرم را دستِ کم به منابع، ابزار، ذهنیت بازیگران، رفتار، آثار و حرکات بازیگران تحت اعمال قدرت محدود نماییم.در یک برداشت کلی قدرت نرم در سطح دولت- ملت ها عبارت است از: فرایندی که در آن محرک ها(منابع مادی و معنوی) یک کشور از طریق رفتار جذاب و در قالب ابزاری غیر خشونت آمیز(انواع و اشکال دیپلماسی)روی افکار مردم(نخبگان و عامه مردم) تاثیر گذاشته و موجب آثار، حرکات و رفتار و... در راستای تغییر ذهنیت و رفتار جامعه هدف، نسبت به کشور اعمال کننده می شود

مراجع

1. Aalam, A.R. (2011). The foundations of policy science. Iran, Tehran: Ney publications [In Persian].

2. Abadis Online Dictionary (2020). Attractiveness, Available via: https://dictionary.abadis.ir/[In Persian].
3. Afzali, R., Zaki, Y., & Dashti, M.H. (2018). Components of the soft power of the Islamic Republic of Iran and its capacities in the international arena from the perspective of experts. Quarterly Journal of Political Studies of the Islamic World, 8(2),121-142[In Persian].
4. Ajili, H., & Esmaili Ardakani, A. (2013). National Justice and Security in International Relations: Islamic Approach. Journal of Strategic Studies, 16(3), 131-158[In Persian].
5. Alhoyi Nazari, H., & Mohammadi, A. (2015). Analysis of the Dimensions of the Principle of Goodwill in International Law in the Light of Judicial Procedure. International Law Review, 32(53), 99-126[In Persian].
6. Asgari, M. (2010). A Critical Approach to Soft Power Theory. Defense Strategy Quarterly, 8(28), 61-86[In Persian].
7. Chegnizadeh, GHA., & Seyfi, Y.(2012). The Capacity of International Ideas in Soft Power Production. Quarterly of Foreign Relations, 4(3), 203-242[In Persian].
8. Cull, Nicholas J. (2008). Public Diplomacy: Lessons from the Past. Iran, Tehran: Faculty and Research Institute of Information and Security Press [In Persian].
9. Daneshnia, F. (2013). The Concept of Power Contraction and Expansion in the Intellectual Framework of J. Nye. Journal of Contemporary Political Investigations, 4(3), 67-87[In Persian].
10. Darroodi, F.(2010). Critique Article: A Framework for Providing Useful and Efficient Information. Monthly of Book of the Month of General, 13(149), 68-74[In Persian].
11. Darroodi, F.(2014). An Introduction to Types of Criticism and Its Functions. Book Critique Quarterly, 1(3-4), 221-234[In Persian].
12. Dehghani Firoozabadi, S.J., & Zolfaghari, M. (2014). British Soft Power Analysis. Two Quarterly of Soft Power Studies, 4(11), 79-106. [In Persian].
13. Eltiyaminia, R., & Taqvaeinia, A. (2016). Explaining the role and position of soft power in achieving the goals of domestic and foreign policy. Quarterly Journal of Political Research in Islamic World, 6(3), 167-196. [In Persian].
14. Ernst & Young company and The Skolkovo Institute for Emerging Market Studies (2012). Rapid-growth markets soft power index, Available from: http://www.ey.com/GL/en/Issues/Driving-growth/Rapid-growth-markets-soft-power-index-Soft-power-variables
15. Esmaili, M.(2017). Homegrown Pattern on Soft Power of the Islamic Republic of Iran, A model for empowering regional actors. Quarterly of Politics, 47(4), 853-871. [In Persian].
16. Esmaili, M. (2017). Homegrown Pattern on Soft Power of the Islamic Republic of Iran, A model for empowering regional actors. Iran, Tehran: Mokhatab Publishing[In Persian].
17. Farhadi, M., & and Moradian, M. (2008). Understanding Soft Power; (Looking at the Islamic Republic of Iran), Proceedings of the National Conference on Basij and Soft Power. Iran, Tehran: Imam Sadegh University Press[In Persian].
18. Fan, Ying (2008). Soft power: Power of attraction or confusion?. Place Branding and Public Diplomacy, Vol. 4, 147–158
19. Fatahi Ardakani, H., Massoud Nia, H., & Imam Jomehzadeh, S.J. (2018). Analysis of the concept of power and its constituent resources from the perspective of Joseph Nye (Hard, soft and smart). two quarterly of soft power studies, 8(18), 130-152[In Persian].
20. Golshanpajooh, M.R. (2012). The Role of the Intelligence Organization in Promoting the Soft Power of the Country. Journal of Strategic Studies, 15(2),117-140[In Persian].
21. Gunek, Abdulsamet (2018)A New Type of Soft Power: Country Branding. International Journal of Cultural and Social Studies, 4(1), 252-259
22. Hadian, N., & Ahadi, A. (2009). The Conceptual Position of Public Diplomacy. Foreign Relations Quarterly, 1(3), 85-117. [In Persian].
23. Kazemi, A. (2011). Social Justice in the Domestic Policy of the Islamic State from the Perspective of the Holy Quran. Farhang-e-Pajuhesh Magazine, 4(10), 1-29 [In Persian].
24. Lynch, M. (2008). Public Opinion Survey Research and Public Diplomacy. Iran, Tehran: Faculty and Research Institute of Information and Security Press [In Persian].
25. Mahdavi, A.A., & Naderi Bab Anari, M. (2012) Application of Soft Power From the area of arrogant; Quranic Approach. Two Quarterly of Political Knowledge, 7(14), 167-204[In Persian].
26. Mah Pishanian, M. (2011). A sociological look at the cultural contexts and social contexts of soft war, a collection of selected articles from the soft war conference. Iran, Mashhad: Zolal Andisheh Publications[In Persian].
27. Mattern, J.B. (2005)Why ‘soft power’ isn’t so soft: representational force and attraction in world politics, Millennium. Journal of International Studies, 33(3), 583-612.
28. McClory, J., Koh, L., Neill, K., & Ghosn, H.(2018). Wales Soft Power Barometer” Measuring soft power beyond the nation-state. British Council Wales, press: British Council Wales.
29. Mousavi Jashni, S.A.S. (2014). Analytical Pattern of Soft Power of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Islamic World. Quarterly of Political Thought in Islam, 1(1),157-190. [In Persian].
30. Mousavi zare, S.J. (2020). Evaluation of effective variables on soft power and Design of countries soft power measurement model, doctoral dissertation(In the process of compiling), Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. /[In Persian].
31. Naeini, A.M. (2012). Principles and foundations of soft war. Iran, Tehran: Saqi Publishing[In Persian].
32. Najm Roshan, S., & Mohammadi Meymand, M. (2017). National Reputation; Concepts, Challenges and Approaches. Journal of Business Administration Researches, 9(18), 269-298. [In Persian].
33. Nye, J. (2007). The benefits of soft power. (Baligh, N., Trans.). Basij Studies Quarterly, 10(36), 107-115 [In Persian].
34. Nye, J. (2008). Power in the Global information Age: From Realism to Globalization, Translation: Saeed Mir Torabi. Iran, Tehran: Research Institute for Strategic Studies[In Persian].
35. Nye, J. (2010). Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics. Rouhani S.M. & Zolfaghari, M. Trans.). Iran, Tehran: Imam Sadiq University Press [In Persian].
36. Nye, J. (2014). The future of power. (Azizi, A. Trans.). Iran, Tehran: Ney publications [In Persian].

1. Parmar, I., & Cox, M. (2010). Soft Power and US Foreign Policy,Theoretical, historical and contemporary perspectives. (Tayyeb, A., Trans.). Iran, Tehran: Strategic Studies Research Institute Press [In Persian].

38. Pishgahi Fard, Z., Farahani, M.,& Moblaghi, A. (2015). Presenting a multi- fuzzy decision model to compare the soft power of countries. Quarterly of World Politics, 4(3), 7-34. [In Persian].
39. portland Institute (2015). The Soft Power 30, Global Soft Power Rankings.(Center for Strategic Studies, Trans.). Iran, Tehran: Center for Strategic Studies Press [In Persian].
40. Qanbarloo, A. (2011). Soft Power Patterns in the Middle East. Quarterly of Soft Power Studies, 1(1), 7-36. [In Persian].
41. Rahmani, M. (2015). Public Diplomacy and Foreign Policy. Quarterly of Strategic Studies of Globalization, 6(15), 63-89. [In Persian].
42. Russett, B., &Starr, H. (2002). World Politics: The Menu for Choice. (Omidi, A., Trans.).Tehran: Ministry of Foreign Affairs Printing and Publishing Center[In Persian].

1. Saeedi, R.A., & Moghadamfar, H.R. (2014). Soft Power Resources of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Two Quarterly of Soft Power Studies, 4(11). 107-126[In Persian].

44. Salehi Amiri, S.R., & Mohammadi, S. (2010). Cultural Diplomacy. Iran, Tehran: qoqnoos Press [In Persian].
45. Seyf, A.M. (2011). Conceptualization of Soft Economic Power of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Quarterly of Afaqe Amniyat, 4(11), 5-38[In Persian].

1. Seyf, A.M., Eftekhari, A., Ezzati, M., & Ramezani, M.T. (2013). Conceptualism of Soft Economic Power: Development of Conventional Soft Power Theory in Economics. Basij Strategic Studies Quarterly, 6(58), 5-36[In Persian].

47. Shakeri Kho'e, E. (2013). Cultural confrontation and soft power in the relations between the Islamic Republic of Iran and the United States of America. Journal of Islamic Revolution Studies, 10(32), 167-186. [In Persian].
48. Simonyi, A., & Trunkos, J. (2014) Spectral Power: Eliminating the Hard/Soft Power Dichotomy. Smarter Power Working Paper Series, Center for Transatlantic Relations Johns Hopkins University
49. Soleymani, A. (2016). A problem called Attraction, published on a personal blog, Recovered: 21 September 2016, Available via: https://ibehtar.ir/[In Persian].

1. Tracy, B., & Arden, R. (2009). The Power of Charm. (Malmir, Kh., Trans.). Iran, Qom: Ashkzar Publishing[In Persian].

51. Vahedi Fard, S. (2011). Evaluation of Immunization Theory in Persuasive Soft War, a collection of selected articles from the soft war conference. Iran, Mashhad: Zolal Andisheh Publications [In Persian].
52. Vuving, A.L. (2009). How soft power works. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association annual meeting Toronto, September 3, 2009,

1. Website of Hi doctor Journal (2017). Definition of Attractiveness from a Psychological Perspective, Recovered: 23 June 2017, Available at: https://www.hidoctor.ir/256323
2. Yousefi, J. (2008). A Comparative Study of Soft Power. in Islamic Discourse and Liberal Democracy, Proceedings of the National Conference on Basij and Soft Power. Iran, Tehran: Imam Sadegh University Press[In Persian].
3. Zakarian, M., & Emadi, S.R. (2015). Analysis of Al-Jazeera Media's Performance in Strengthening Qatar's Soft Power. Journal of Strategic Studies, 18(67), 69-96[In Persian].