Until a few decades ago, most development scholars believed that development and democracy were in a state of tension or conflict in the Third World. However, as the number of democracies in the Global South increased and democracy became a popular demand, development studies also began to explore ways of reconciling democracy and development. The theoretical literature on the Democratic Developmental State as a subsidiary branch of the broader theoretical framework of the Developmental State is one of the most significant manifestations of these efforts.
Three decades after the emergence of this intellectual trend, this article asks whether the research programme on the Democratic Developmental State has succeeded in achieving its objective of reconciling democracy and development. To answer this question, Imre Lakatos’s methodology of scientific research programmes is employed to appraise the Democratic Developmental State research programme along three dimensions. The findings indicate that the programme has entered a degenerative phase on all three. First, it has failed to introduce new concepts or mechanisms capable of explaining and analysing empirical reality. Second, it has been compelled to impose increasingly restrictive qualifications and conditions in order to protect its hard core. Third, it has largely failed to identify compelling and credible empirical cases of democratic developmental states.
A further, ancillary finding also emerged from this study. An examination of the key works within the broader theoretical framework of the Developmental State suggests that this framework developed in an intellectual climate in which normative pressures, both external and internalized, made it particularly difficult to acknowledge authoritarianism as one of the defining characteristics of East Asian developmental states.
Jalali Javaran, M. H. & Kazemi, H. (2026). Both Developmental and Democratic? A Critical Appraisal of the Democratic Developmental State Research Programme. (e49140). Research Political Geography Quarterly, (), e49140 https://doi.org/10.22067/pg.2026.100681.1469
MLA
Jalali Javaran, M. H., & Kazemi, H. "Both Developmental and Democratic? A Critical Appraisal of the Democratic Developmental State Research Programme" .e49140 , Research Political Geography Quarterly, , 2026, e49140. doi: 10.22067/pg.2026.100681.1469
HARVARD
Jalali Javaran, M. H., & Kazemi, H. (2026). 'Both Developmental and Democratic? A Critical Appraisal of the Democratic Developmental State Research Programme', Research Political Geography Quarterly, (), e49140. doi: 10.22067/pg.2026.100681.1469
CHICAGO
Jalali Javaran, M. H. & Kazemi, H., "Both Developmental and Democratic? A Critical Appraisal of the Democratic Developmental State Research Programme." Research Political Geography Quarterly, (2026): e49140, doi: 10.22067/pg.2026.100681.1469
VANCOUVER
Jalali Javaran M. H., Kazemi H. Both Developmental and Democratic? A Critical Appraisal of the Democratic Developmental State Research Programme. PG. 2026;():e49140 (In Persian). doi: 10.22067/pg.2026.100681.1469